Finally, The Undetectables concludes.
This has certainly been an interesting story—and that’s not praise I give lightly. While the ending does reveal the true identity of “The Whistler,” it turns out he isn’t who the Undetectables believed him to be. Unfortunately, the reasoning behind his actions feels ill-conceived and emotionally shallow.
The character of Jacob Gabert appears throughout the investigation but seems largely insignificant, mostly offering minor assistance here and there. As a result, readers—like the protagonists—are unlikely to give him much consideration. Yet once it's revealed that he is the villain, his presence retroactively gains weight. That said, his motives are where the narrative begins to unravel.
For comparison, take Barty Crouch Jr. from Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. In the book, he’s implicated in the torture of Neville Longbottom’s parents, though he pleads innocence—particularly to his mother—suggesting he may have been guilty by association, not by action. His father’s political position made him a convenient scapegoat. The emotional rejection by his father becomes central to his later descent. Disguised as a trusted authority, he spends most of the fourth book secretly aiding Harry—not to help him, but to deliver him to Voldemort in hopes of being welcomed as a loyal son.
Jacob shares similar emotional wounds. He is the illegitimate son of Night Mayor Van Doran and a non-magical human woman. Rejected and emotionally neglected by his father, even when deemed "useful," Jacob begins to believe that summoning the Ternian—a triad of mythical goddesses—will grant him the recognition and belonging he has always craved.
But this motivation doesn't hold up under scrutiny.
First, the Ternian are described as a triumvirate—three divine beings, whether sisters or bonded allies, who symbolize balance and spiritual harmony. The number three has rich mystical significance: the Maiden, Mother, and Crone; the Greek Moirai; the divine trinity found in various esoteric traditions. The Ternian—Elizabella, Hexanna, and Blair—represent creation, healing, and protection. Their lore emphasizes peacekeeping between the magical and non-magical worlds. There is no precedent suggesting they would welcome someone like Jacob, especially not someone whose actions threaten that balance.
In contrast, a Quadernian would represent a fourfold power—creation, healing, protection, and destruction—signifying balance through tension. While the number four also has symbolic power (seasons, elements, directions), the Ternian are rooted in reverence and caution. They are not benevolent deities to be summoned for personal gain, but cosmic forces to be honored and feared.
Furthermore, Jacob’s ultimate confrontation with Mallory and Cornelia exposes the immaturity of his logic. As he prepares to sacrifice them, he laments that they missed the clues he left behind. Because the Undetectables were three women (mirroring the Ternian), he believed their ability—or failure—to catch him would be a divine judgment. If they failed, it meant the Ternian had not rejected him. This rationale is flimsy at best and egocentric to the point of absurdity.
Rather than a misunderstood genius, Jacob comes across as a petulant child—driven not by ideology or deeper belief, but by a desperate need to feel chosen, powerful, and significant. The fact that the Undetectables never cracked his riddles doesn’t signify their failure—it reveals Jacob’s illusions of grandeur. His plan, which could have shattered the balance of the magical world, was not a stroke of brilliance but a reckless tantrum masked in arcane aesthetics.
In the end, The Undetectables remains a compelling story, but its villain's motives lack the narrative maturity to match the world it so carefully built.
Finally, The Undetectables concludes.
This has certainly been an interesting story—and that’s not praise I give lightly. While the ending does reveal the true identity of “The Whistler,” it turns out he isn’t who the Undetectables believed him to be. Unfortunately, the reasoning behind his actions feels ill-conceived and emotionally shallow.
The character of Jacob Gabert appears throughout the investigation but seems largely insignificant, mostly offering minor assistance here and there. As a result, readers—like the protagonists—are unlikely to give him much consideration. Yet once it's revealed that he is the villain, his presence retroactively gains weight. That said, his motives are where the narrative begins to unravel.
For comparison, take Barty Crouch Jr. from Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. In the book, he’s implicated in the torture of Neville Longbottom’s parents, though he pleads innocence—particularly to his mother—suggesting he may have been guilty by association, not by action. His father’s political position made him a convenient scapegoat. The emotional rejection by his father becomes central to his later descent. Disguised as a trusted authority, he spends most of the fourth book secretly aiding Harry—not to help him, but to deliver him to Voldemort in hopes of being welcomed as a loyal son.
Jacob shares similar emotional wounds. He is the illegitimate son of Night Mayor Van Doran and a non-magical human woman. Rejected and emotionally neglected by his father, even when deemed "useful," Jacob begins to believe that summoning the Ternian—a triad of mythical goddesses—will grant him the recognition and belonging he has always craved.
But this motivation doesn't hold up under scrutiny.
First, the Ternian are described as a Triumvirate—three divine beings, whether sisters or bonded allies, who symbolize balance and spiritual harmony. The number three has rich mystical significance: the Maiden, Mother, and Crone; the Greek Moirai; the divine trinity found in various esoteric traditions. The Ternian—Elizabella, Hexanna, and Blair—represent creation, healing, and protection. Their lore emphasizes peacekeeping between the magical and non-magical worlds. There is no precedent suggesting they would welcome someone like Jacob, especially not someone whose actions threaten that balance.
In contrast, the Quadernian represent a fourfold power—creation, healing, protection, and destruction—signifying balance through tension. While the number four also has symbolic power (seasons, elements, directions), the Ternian are rooted in reverence and caution. They are not benevolent deities to be summoned for personal gain, but cosmic forces to be honored and feared.
Furthermore, Jacob’s ultimate confrontation with Mallory and Cornelia exposes the immaturity of his logic. As he prepares to sacrifice them, he laments that they missed the clues he left behind. Because the Undetectables were three women (mirroring the Ternian), he believed their ability—or failure—to catch him would be a divine judgment. If they failed, it meant the Ternian had not rejected him. This rationale is flimsy at best, and egocentric to the point of absurdity.
Rather than a misunderstood genius, Jacob comes across as a petulant child—driven not by ideology or deeper belief, but by a desperate need to feel chosen, powerful, and significant. The fact that the Undetectables never cracked his riddles doesn’t signify their failure—it reveals Jacob’s illusions of grandeur. His plan, which could have shattered the balance of the magical world, was not a stroke of brilliance but a reckless tantrum masked in arcane aesthetics.
In the end, The Undetectables remains a compelling story, but its villain's motives lack the narrative maturity to match the world it so carefully built.
Final Thoughts on The Undetectables
The Undetectables has been a fascinating and often ambitious story, one that doesn’t shy away from weaving together mystery, magic, and layered worldbuilding. Across its chapters, it delivered strong character dynamics, compelling female leads, and a setting where occult politics and investigative grit collide in satisfying ways. It kept me engaged, offered rich thematic material (like the post-Vampire War covenant and the role of magical ethics), and introduced lore that was genuinely intriguing.
However, the ending didn’t quite live up to the promise of the build-up.
The reveal of Jacob Gabert as The Whistler felt underwhelming—not because of the twist itself, but because his motivations lacked coherence and emotional depth. While the idea of a neglected son seeking cosmic validation could have worked, the execution was muddled. His attempt to equate his rejection with divine acceptance by the Ternian never felt earned, nor did it align with the mythos the book spent so much time developing. The goddesses were a force of balance, not salvation, and his understanding of them came across as shallow—even self-serving.
His comparisons to figures like Barty Crouch Jr. suggest that the narrative wanted us to see him as a tragic villain—but unlike Crouch, whose descent felt complex and tied to real-world emotional consequences, Jacob came off more as a delusional child than a truly dangerous mastermind.
In the end, The Undetectables was absolutely worth reading. It had a rich atmosphere, powerful themes about identity and justice, and moments of real tension. But its final note rang a little hollow—not because the villain was unexpected, but because he wasn’t compelling enough to carry the weight of everything the story tried to say.
Still, I don’t regret the journey. The lore, the women of the Undetectables, and the broader ideas about magical accountability were all strong enough to make this a story I’ll remember.
No comments:
Post a Comment